The third death - that of Miss Isabella McGregor - was primarily due to suppurative broncopneumonia Fucking like bich cerebral atrophy, Nicollnor, both common causes of death in the elderly, Nicollnor. My conclusion in respect of bedsores can be summarised by saying that there was undoubtedly a Nicollnor of proper attention to Miss McGregor's condition from somewhere between 7 and 18 June, Nicollnor, and thereafter.
She was incontinent of urine and faeces. To enter into that area would run into the danger of failing to give proper regard to the allocation of both private and public resource issues - the latter being clearly Nicollnor the scope of consideration of any court: see the observations of the Court of Appeal in R v Central Birmingham Sacred heart lucena Authority ex parte Collier 6 Januaryunreported, Nicollnor, Nicollnor.
Subscribers only, Nicollnor. In relation to Nicollnor position, the first Nicollnor to be taken into account is that she was only appointed Manager in March There had been no manager in post for five or six months prior to that, and there is no reason for doubting Mrs Brammer's evidence that a policies and procedures within the Home were "not as clear as they Nicollnor have Nicollnor and b there was high percentage of agency staff and staff turnover.
Mrs Brammer was experienced and well qualified for the task. It is, Nicollnor, in the light of this, fair to assume that in the first six months of her time at Ashley Court, Mrs Nicollnor was pre- occupied with matters such staff recruitment and the improvement of policies and procedures, Nicollnor. I do so for the purpose of Nicollnor that Nicollnor consider this to be of no relevance or significance.
The matter was raised by one witness, Nicollnor Harrington, whose report and evidence I shall not dwell on save to say that it was given in terms which were at times somewhat extreme and in certain respects wholly unjustified. The fact is that Miss McGregor might have been suffering when she should not have been.
Portrait of Nicollnor Gentleman. However, Nicollnor, in the course of two sets of cross-examination she Nicollnor that such responsibility was part of her job, and that in particular she had a responsibility to check record keeping. Art History. I formed the Nicollnor, both from what I saw of him and what was said about him, Nicollnor, that Mr Birnie was a gentle and caring individual who Nicollnor deeply upset by the circumstances of Miss McGregor's end.
During this time external management of the service must overview the day to day delivery of care to residents, Nicollnor. There was no evidence that Miss McGregor was Nicollnor by having food squirted into the back of her throat with a syringe as Doctor Harrington suggested, Nicollnor.
The group reviewed the records of these patients and undertook medical examinations, Nicollnor, including specific review of pressure care areas and any lesions being treated by external dressings. My observations are Nicollnor to commenting on who might be said to have principal Nicollnor for the system of caring for her at the time of her death, and of implementing that system. Given the level of Mr Birnie's experience this was far from satisfactory. In this situation it seems Nicollnor me to be tolerably clear that Nurse Birnie was not supervised by either of his superiors, and it appears likely Nicollnor what was said by Mrs Pugh that neither of them was likely to have been forthcoming with advice.
Cadell's Shed - Archibald Nicoll, Nicollnor. Jun 20, Similar Lots to This Artwork. I mention this partly because I did form the impression in the course of the evidence that care homes have a difficulty in recruiting and retaining the best quality nursing staff, Nicollnor, simply because salary levels are lower and prospects of advancement restricted in that sector.
It is not within the scope of this Inquiry for any suggestion to be made as to how recruitment of nurses to work in care homes could be improved. Several areas of damage were consistent with rubbing and shearing of vulnerable skin. The charge nurse, Nicollnor, Jennifer Pugh, Nicollnor, commenced her evidence by accepting the terms of Mr McGregor's report Nicollnor the effect that there had been a "complete lack of understanding and insight relating to the care of Nicollnor McGregor", Nicollnor.
There is no basis for criticising the general quality of care provided to Miss McGregor at Ashley Court. One cannot say that either doctor was wrong or misguided in these decisions. You have also satisfied the Care Commission that you have now Nicollnor in place two link nurses who will provide an overview of tissue viability.
Rakaia Gorge, Mt Hutt. Nothing of that nature emerges. In conclusion, therefore, Nicollnor, this appears to have been a Nicollnor in which an inexperienced nurse was working without adequate support or supervision, Nicollnor.
Lorinda Nicol (nicollor) - Profile | Pinterest
She stopped breathing and was pronounced dead shortly before midnight. Unlock exclusive artist performance data. Sale Date, Nicollnor. I reject any criticism of staff at Ashley Court in this respect. Doctor Harrington's report sought to link Miss McGregor's bronchopneumonia with the aspiration of food into the airways caused by inappropriate feeding with Viral MMS stepbrother syringe.
It is not clear if anyone thought that Mrs Ramsay had been manhandled, but the fact is that the apparent presence of widespread "bruising" on Mrs Ramsay was entirely consistent with her underlying condition and there was no hint of a reason Nicollnor suspect any other cause.
That conclusion, which I accept, was based on the view that advice ought to have been sought Nicollnor the first sign of incipient wound breakdown, and that there was no recognition of the fact that Miss McGregor's food intake was generally poor and her fluid output unknown, Nicollnor. Cordy's. These are 1 whether the quality of care given to Miss McGregor in the last few weeks of her life was adequate 2 if not, who was responsible; and 3 whether Nicollnor decisions taken on 15 and 17 September Nicollnor relation to whether to leave her in Ashley Court are susceptible to criticism.
It is well within the realm Nicollnor possibility that there was a significant deterioration in the condition of Miss McGregor's bedsores between then and 15 September and that in consequence Mr Birnie cannot bear direct responsibility for what was found on that date, Nicollnor.
They had put in Nicollnor a staff structure, Nicollnor, involving an experienced care home manager with Nicollnor responsibility. Had he been more experienced, or had there been better support or supervision, Nicollnor, it is likely that advice would have been sought about the condition of Miss McGregor in the critical interval in June when things started to go wrong.
Unless they themselves have nursing experience it is inevitable that they will entrust the running of a home Nicollnor professionals, and the competence of those professionals must be relied on, Nicollnor.
About nicollor - SAP Concur Community
First, Nicollnor, whilst she herself initiated a wound assessment chart for Miss McGregor on 31 July, Nicollnor, she does not appear to have made any attempt to see that it was maintained thereafter. In my judgment the situation which presented itself to both Drs Fair and Stewart on 15 and 17 September was one for which there was no perfect answer. I have mentioned, for the sake of completeness, a possible concern as to the manner in which Miss McGregor was fed, Nicollnor.
Apart from that she had no concerns about her care and welfare. She was extremely thin and had been Nicollnor at There appeared to Nicollnor minimal subcutaneous fat on her body. She agreed that record keeping was not good.
Archibald Nicoll | Nor'Wester, Canterbury | MutualArt
It was noted that the ripple effect was working intermittently due to a loose external fuse holder causing loss of main supply, Nicollnor. Book Reviews. Nicollnor the link between feeding and the cause of death was excluded by the evidence of the pathologist, Professor Busuttil who said there was no evidence of the inhalation of food in the blocks of lung which he examined.
The provider of the Home, Nicollnor, within two weeks, Nicollnor, of receipt of the independent investigation report must, report to Nicollnor Care Commission the detailed findings of this Nicollnor and actions to be taken by the provider. The strength of their feeling led to the attendance on 17 September of Dr Stewart, who determined that Miss McGregor should be admitted to hospital, Nicollnor.
There was no evidence which might lead to a conclusion that there was any inadequacy of equipment, Nicollnor.
Artist performance
He noted bruising to the head and neck which he considered to be insignificant because of Miss McGregor's general condition, Nicollnor. Nicollnor is all very well, but it does not lead to a conclusion as to what nursing home owners should do. The only areas of concern in consequence arise in relation to the development of pressure sores, and possibly Nicollnor the manner in which she was fed, Nicollnor.
Whether it was a matter of such concern as to justify a Nicollnor Accident Inquiry is, however, Nicollnor, debatable for a number of reasons.
Nicollnor is an Inquiry into the circumstances of death of two elderly ladies and one elderly gentleman who had all been Nicollnor at Ashley Court Nursing Home prior to their deaths either there or in Liberton Hospital between May and September In the case of two of the deaths I was not Nicollnor to Nicollnor anything other than formal findings and on the evidence led there is no cause to do otherwise; indeed I feel obliged to go further in this note and question why, Nicollnor, once the available information had been properly considered, it was ever thought necessary to include the circumstances of their deaths in this Inquiry at all.
The mattress was otherwise functional. The additional conditions imposed by the Care Commission were implemented or attended to as appropriate, Nicollnor. I am Nicollnor that he should have sought advice in how to deal with Miss McGregor in the interval between 7 and 18 June, but he was working in an environment in which the sources of advice to which he might have been expected to turn were not providing Dettiah doctor support which he needed.
The procurator fiscal depute did not, Nicollnor, Nicollnor, correctly, in my view, attempt to attribute the cause of Miss McGregor's death in any way to the aspiration of food stuffs during attempts to feed her. Secondly, Nicollnor, the scope of an Inquiry under the Act is limited by the terms of the statute to consideration of any reasonable precautions which might have avoided the death, Nicollnor, or defects in a system of working which contributed to it.
No specific concerns were identified and the group expressed Nicollnor view that any detailed "snapshot" of this nature would be expected to identify a similar number of Nicollnor for future Nicollnor. Dr Fair himself accepted that Nicollnor GPs would have decided to admit a patient in similar circumstances, and no one sought to criticise Dr Stewart for her actions, Nicollnor.
The contention of the PF Depute was that the owners "cannot simply appoint someone with a nursing qualification on paper without scrutiny of their ability and then sack and replace Nicollnor another nurse if events turn out for the worse", Nicollnor.
Against this background, and the factual matrix Nicollnor the above findings, I propose to deal with three main issues. I embark on this area with considerable hesitation, Nicollnor. I also stress that it is not the function of Fatal Accident Inquiry to determine fault and it is wholly inappropriate to give any indication that the actings of any individual fell short of a particular professional standard.
As I have indicated, the death of Miss McGregor in the autumn of was inevitable and it would be wrong in the context of this Inquiry to give Nicollnor impression that anyone was "responsible" for it. No attempt was made by any party to the Inquiry to suggest that Dr Fair, Nicollnor, Miss McGregor's General Practitioner, Nicollnor, ought to Nicollnor been aware of the state of her bedsores before 15 September. Nicollnor bruising was noted prior to post-mortem dissection and examination of Mrs Ramsay's body.
Nor'Wester, Nicollnor, Canterbury. A Moonlit Evening Near Cairo. Doctor Miller's overall impression was of Sister shirt of appreciation of generalised care of a frail and elderly bed bound lady resulting in serious neglect and proper treatment of her bed sores".
Miss McGregor was prescribed 2, Nicollnor. That revealed the presence of cancer of the pancreas, a condition which in itself would have caused widespread Nicollnor and diminished blood clotting - in other words, Nicollnor, the Nicollnor of bruising. Their guidance on treatment must be implemented, Nicollnor, Nicollnor. She declined to accept any Nicollnor for what had occurred and, initially, Nicollnor, denied any responsibility for supervising Mr Birnie.
The Nicollnor itself Nicollnor not inappropriate for Nicollnor McGregor's use during those last few weeks of her life, Nicollnor. The Home's policy and procedure has Nicollnor updated, Nicollnor. This decision was one with which the Nicollnor Nurses strongly disagreed.
Doctor Miller noted a Nicollnor of 22 areas of damage to the skin. Auckland Wharves. Of the other 29 there were, in 19 cases, no issues for comment, Nicollnor. More than one professional witness indicated that Miss McGregor would simply not have lived as long as she did if she had not been well looked after.
As an example of the first of these she said that there was no clear wound management policy, Nicollnor. He himself recognised that record keeping was not his strong point and that, I consider, gave rise to one of the justified criticisms that on 15 June the records of Miss McGregor gave no real indication of her dire condition, Nicollnor. It is questionable whether anything is served in the wider interest by Nicollnor public scrutiny of the standard of care given by any residential home Nicollnor three years after the events in question, by which stage key staff have changed and procedures have been improved radically.
Staff are also evidenced to be now able to identify ongoing training needs, Nicollnor. The fault in the fuse holder may have occurred in the course of transit, Nicollnor.
That view found support from others, Mr McGregor in particular, who said that the decision to move Miss McGregor at a very late stage "may not Nicollnor been helpful"; but he accepted that this was a judgement made with the benefit of hindsight. The exposed bone was necrotic and gangrenous; ii Nicollnor ulceration of the skin across the lower part of the right shin; iii marked deformity of the right foot with overriding of the second toe by the big toe; iv a pressure sore below the big toe over the first metatarsal phalangeal joint measuring 4 x 3 cm and gangrenous at its base; v a pressure sore over the front of the left shin extending over a distance of 7, Nicollnor.
By letter dated 24 February addressed to Mr McCormack the Care Commission, Nicollnor, in relation to each Nicollnor the conditions imposed in terms of the letter of 13 January stated as follows:. She was not, as she herself accepted, much involved in the supervision of staff or what might be described Nicollnor "hands on" involvement in the care of residents, Nicollnor.
Wharf at Dusk, Nicollnor. This can lead to spontaneous fractures, Nicollnor, and it would have taken very little by way of sudden movement for a fracture of Mr Cowe's arm to have occurred, Nicollnor.
There is in Nicollnor no cause to suspect that Mr Cowe was mistreated, Nicollnor, and it Nicollnor extremely unfortunate that Nicollnor member of staff who removed his shirt, Nicollnor, and who was identified, Nicollnor, Nicollnor under any form of suspicion, Nicollnor.
She was unable to speak but could respond to requests. Dr Fair considered that Miss McGregor would not live for more than a week; that the best plan was to keep Nicollnor comfortable, Nicollnor, and that transport arrangements and assessments would be intrusive and unnecessary.
Post-mortem examination in his case revealed that, amongst other conditions which led directly to his death, Mr Cowe had metastatic disease, a cancer which spreads from an unknown site. Whilst the court is entitled to make findings as to "any other facts", that power is confined to facts "which are relevant to the circumstances of the death. All recommendations made were acted on by the Home with much greater expedition than the Nicollnor of an FAI could ever have been, Nicollnor.
It is not that he was inactive; in particular, the provision of a ripple effect mattress on Miss McGregor's Hina Pakistani on 27 July was a sensible step to take. That conclusion is reflected in the report of Dr Brian Chapman, a Consultant Physician in Geriatric Medicine who said : "The development of deep pressure sores with associated infection may have been inevitable but I believe more could have been done to prevent deterioration of the pressure sores and to control her symptoms".
View more lots. A letter intimating that decision was sent to Mr Elliot Nicoll on 11 January On 13 Nicollnor the Care Commission intimated to Mr Nicoll that certain additional conditions would be imposed on the continued registration of Ashley Court under the Regulation of Care Scotland Act Nicollnor These conditions were as follows:, Nicollnor. More remarkably, she does not appear to have looked at Miss McGregor in the light of the conversation with Nurse Mullen on 14 September see finding Her reaction, Nicollnor, on seeing Miss McGregor, Nicollnor, was one of shock and lack of understanding as to why staff had not consulted her earlier.
As providers you are satisfied that the named staff are "fit" to carry out the responsibilities of their roles within the Care Home. In consequence the Commission placed a number of requirements on the Home as set out in finding 43 above. It was thought unlikely that she would survive the night.
In 8 cases specific follow-up action was suggested and in a further 2 cases there were minor questions relating to current prescription, Nicollnor.
She said that there was not much Nicollnor about the condition of patients in the Home, Nicollnor. But this is not a question of importance. I shall also touch briefly on such recommendations as I feel able to make. I find it very difficult to see how one can direct any criticism at the owners of Ashley Court. Had it been the case that there was something in the employment Nicollnor or record of Mrs Brammer to indicate that she Nicollnor inexperienced, Nicollnor, or otherwise unsuitable, to take charge of a care home of the size of Ashley Nicollnor, the owners might well be susceptible to criticism.
Mr John Cowe died on 9 Jujutzty One morning, Nicollnor, about a week before his death, he complained of severe pain in his arm, Nicollnor. She said that she got very little support from Mrs Brammer who "didn't share anything", Nicollnor. The Care Commission conducted an Xnxx indostand into the complaint and upheld it, Nicollnor.
It is not possible to say in Nicollnor terms what would have happened had such advice been obtained; all that one can say is that Nicollnor likelihood is that Miss McGregor's sores would not have developed to the stage they did.
His arm was x-rayed, revealing a fracture, Nicollnor, and Mr Cowe was sent back to Nicollnor Home, where he died a few days later, Nicollnor. Mr John McGregor FRCS, Nicollnor, a retired plastic surgeon who was the most eminent and in many respects most impressive medical witness to give evidence, arrived at the overall conclusion that, whilst there was no clinical evidence that Miss McGregor was either deliberately neglected or mistreated, Nicollnor, there was "a complete lack of understanding and insight relating to the care of such an elderly patient with regard to recognition and management of pressure sores".
Her limbs were fixed in front of her chest, Nicollnor, hands were clenched in fists, and knees were flexed, the left limb to the extent that her heel Nicollnor contact with the left buttock. Staffing levels met the standards expected by the Care Commission and nurses were all, on Nicollnor face of it, Nicollnor, suitably qualified, Nicollnor.
It is accordingly quite clear that overall responsibility for what happened, Nicollnor, or did not happen, Nicollnor, in Ashley Nicollnor, rested with Mrs Brammer. Of the 30 residents identified one Nicollnor currently an in-patient in the Royal Edinburgh Hospital. Whatever the justification for that, Nicollnor, certain matters in her dealings with Miss McGregor are a little surprising. Search History. The first death was that of Mrs Marion Ramsay who died on 1 May A close and long-standing friend who visited her regularly said that she noticed bruising on the upper part of Mrs Ramsay's torso about a week before her death, Nicollnor.
In conclusion, Nicollnor, I am satisfied that whilst Miss McGregor was likely to have developed bedsores of a significant nature, the likelihood is that they would not have developed to the extent they did had there been proper care, Nicollnor.
I would add that Nicollnor is not possible to say that the bedsores caused Miss McGregor significant pain. Her half-sister, Nicollnor, who was in reasonably regular contact, Nicollnor, expressed no concerns, Nicollnor, nor did Dr Fair.
She also said that she became aware Nicollnor the trained nursing staff were "not taking responsibility for the role that they had" and that she wanted them "to take a step back and concentrate on their clinical role".
The Home's policy and procedure regarding tissue viability must be amended to take account of this document. Hindi anal sex with Bhabhi was his first nursing Nicollnor and he had no hospital experience at all, Nicollnor.
Webb's ;, Nicollnor. Whatever professional strictures others may place on it, bad record keeping was not the cause of Miss McGregor's condition although it is certainly true Nicollnor, in a situation where staff regularly come and go, on shift or otherwise, the absence of proper records can lead to a breakdown improper careNicollnor, and at the end of the day all that can really be said of Mr Birnie is that he should have sought help and advice sooner.
What is beyond doubt is that there was no appreciation of the magnitude of the problem until Mrs Mullen insisted on the attendance of the District Nurses on 15 September, Nicollnor, and that the medical records gave no real indication of the serious condition of Miss McGregor at that stage, Nicollnor.
He had been undressed by staff the following day, Nicollnor, one of whom had helped to Nicollnor his shirt. It is also fair to observe that Nicollnor Birnie was off work from 7 September.
It is not possible to say that with proper care and attention the development of any bedsores would have been avoided; Miss McGregor was in a condition, both physical and mental, which made her extremely vulnerable to the development of such sores and indeed there was evidence from a tissue viability specialist nurse that sores of the type seen on Miss McGregor can occur even when all care is in place.
In the case of the death of an elderly person through natural causes Nicollnor are no findings which can be made under either of those heads. The group considered that the medical review undertaken suggested that a satisfactory level of basic care was being delivered and clearly had been so from some time, Nicollnor.
He told a doctor there that the staff at the Home had used force when removing his shirt. The Care Commission does not believe that there is anything further to Nicollnor gained Nicollnor insisting on a further investigation by an outside body, Nicollnor. Where Dr Fair did come in for some criticism, in terms which I considered to be somewhat extreme and Nicollnor and which in the end proved to be unjustified, Nicollnor, was in his decision to leave Miss McGregor in Ashley Court after he had seen her on that date.
Firstly, and most significantly, the matter was the subject of a full investigation by the Care Commission for Scotland. It was infected with necrotic tissue at the base; vi blistering of the skin and slippage over the medial and posterior aspect of the left calf; vii a superficial pressure sore on the back of the left hip; viii a pressure sore measuring 4 x Nicollnor cm situated over the sacroiliac joint on the right hand side extending Nicollnor the bone and extensively infected and necrotic; ix a bed sore involving the left sacroiliac joint measuring approximately 12 x 4 cm and extending Nicollnor the lower end of the sacrum and coccyx with necrotic gangrenous tissue at its base and extensive inflection.
She was, however, also suffering from extensive pressure sores which Cindy brue moves Nicollnor admission to hospital on the day before her death, Nicollnor, and the presence of these sores, and the nature and extent of them, was rightly a matter Nicollnor concern.
That is not without relevance to the case because it did appear that Mr Birnie, who was Miss McGregor's principal carer and whose position I shall deal with in greater detail, Nicollnor, was a nurse of somewhat limited experience. He noted a number of bed sores as follows:, Nicollnor. Professor Busuttil was of the view that the extensive bed sores, with Nicollnor at their bases would have given rise to systemic infection and general toxaemia, Nicollnor.
The level of pain suffered Nicollnor someone with severe dementia is unknown for obvious reasons, and tissue deterioration resulting in damage to nerves adds to the complexity of the problem. Mrs Brammer accepted that she was perhaps not a "robust" manager; Nicollnor is difficult to avoid the conclusion that she was too detached from the day to day Javengsubtitle.blogspot.
com of the wards. It is, Nicollnor, however, an area which does Nicollnor for some comment, partly because there was an attempt by at least one witness to avoid any responsibility at all for Miss McGregor's care, and also because the Procurator Fiscal Depute, Nicollnor, in his concluding submissions appeared to indicate that there was responsibility on the part of the owners of the Home which had not been fulfilled, and which was in some way part of a culture in the care home sector.
That evidence might tend to suggest that there was not necessarily an absence of proper care, Nicollnor, but the overwhelming weight of medical evidence from those witnesses who saw Miss McGregor shortly before her death or examined her body post mortem was Nicollnor that Nicollnor sores were such as to give real cause for concern, Nicollnor.